Cointegrating regression OK but EC term insignificant

[Petros]

Hi all,

My cointegrating regression passes Johansen test, I get very good t-stats with correct signs and stationarity of residuals is verified at the 93% confidence level. However, in the regression of first differences the error correction term (the lagged residual of the cointegrating regression) is clearly statistically insignificant and wrong sign. I am not sure how to interpret this. Any suggestions of what this means or what econometric/estimation problem may be due to?

Your help will be greatly appreciated.

Thanks.
Petros

[TomDoan]

Did you estimate both of the error correction equations? It's quite possible for one of the two variables to have a zero loading on the cointegrating vector.

[Petros]

Tom thanks for the reply. Pardon my ignorance but I don't understand which is the other error correction equation you are referring to.

Petros

[TomDoan]

You're looking at one equation out of a VECM. The loading is probably significant in the other equation. For instance, if

cointexample.gif (4.33 KiB) Viewed 7207 times

then the two variables are cointegrated, but all the adjustment is done by x2. If you run a ECM on x1, you'll get a zero coefficient on the cointegrating vector.